SUPPORT US

In the Senate, a little freedom would go a very long way

In_the_Senate_Montages.jpg

OP-ED

by Hugh Segal

Ottawa Citizen
November 21, 2016

Change is rarely easy in longstanding institutions, especially those created by the Fathers of Confederation. It is human nature to slow down and moderate change. The creation of an upper chamber, modelled on the House of Lords at Westminster,‎ was about ensuring that the less populace regions could balance the power of high-populace Ontario. No agreement on a Senate in 1867 would have meant no Confederation.

With the Justin Trudeau government having won a clear mandate to change the Senate in terms of how appointees are vetted, reducing partisan dominance of the chamber and modernizing procedures and resource allocation, it should not be surprising that traditional partisan forces, which held unlimited sway over all decisions that mattered in the Senate, are deeply resistant to‎ the required changes.

Senate Liberals, not formally related to the government caucus in the Commons, and Conservative senators, jealous of the powers they are losing as the Independent senators go from minority to plurality to majority, are not embracing even the notion of change, let alone doing so with even modest urgency. But how can distinguished new senators, with compelling backgrounds in the judiciary, business, policing, human rights, journalism, municipal government, provincial and charitable service, be expected to have only half the rights, privileges or research capacity of their partisan predecessors or partisan colleagues?

The issue is not that one group of senators is better than the other – but that they are all equal. By what logic should a non-partisan academic from B.C. be told that his or her ability to sit on committees, vote, speak or get research done, should be seriously more limited than that of another B.C. senator who was appointed years ago as a Conservative or Liberal?

The partisan powers argue for patience as the rules slowly evolve. Really?  How wildly disengaged from reality!

The notion that regional groupings of senators, including partisans and Independents, would choose facilitators in order to establish operational principles around rules, equality of committee membership rights or research budget allocations at the beginning of every Parliament in no way diminishes or eliminates any role partisans might wish to play.‎ But it does means that partisan caucuses do not get to run the Senate as if the Independent senators, now the largest group, are marginal, or worse, non-existent.

The government representative in the Senate, Peter Harder, has shown surprising and remarkable patience to date while surrounded by partisan excess. He is attempting to implement the mandated plan, as promised by the government, while the Privy Council Office has inexplicably underfunded his operations. Sen. Harder is being asked to oversee all of the changes in the Senate with less than half the money previously given the leader of the Conservative caucus. Perhaps this has something to do with the makeup of the powerful Board of Internal Economy, which comprises a majority of partisan senators eager to retard any change.

The notion that a balanced chamber, where all senators have equal rights, is somehow an attack on partisan differences or options is a classic Hail Mary pass from the more extreme end of the partisan gene pool. Sen. Harder has been charged with ensuring that the business of Parliament gets done in the Senate: the introduction, debate and committee hearings of bills, and a final vote by the Senate that will determine the bill’s fate. Someone has to do it. He does not guarantee the passage of bills without amendment nor does he whip or count votes amongst his Independent colleagues, nor should he. He exhibits no apparent power grab; he does appear to favour a change to more open processes and deliberations.

Those who have thrived on institutional unfairness for decades‎ find the actual reality of fairness hard to accept. Yet Canadians have the absolute right to expect fairness to prevail in an upper chamber where partisan preference no longer runs the entire show. A full 92 per cent of Canadians have never held a party membership. The Senate, at its best, should speak for them as well.

If the prime minister, who deserves immense credit for keeping his promise on Senate reform, is to see it through, he may well consider, after enough legislation has reached first reading in the Senate from the Commons, proroguing Parliament for a day so that under the rubric of a new Parliament, the Independent plurality in the Senate can actually change some rules.

Hugh Segal is Master of Massey College. The Public Policy Forum recently published a paper on Senate reform by former senators Michael Kirby and Hugh Segal.

Image: The Canadian Press

Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTERS
 
UPCOMING EVENTS

CONFERENCE
Annual Defence Procurement Conference

Ottawa, Ontario

October 25, 2022

SEARCH
EXPERTS IN THE MEDIA

G7 Update

by Heather Hiscox (feat. Andrew Rasiulis), CBC, June 30, 2022

Inside Policy: Russia’s invasion of Ukraine

by Editorial Staff (feat. Rob Huebert), MLI, June 30, 2022

Canada to upgrade Latvia battlegroup to a brigade, boost number of troops

by Editorial Staff (feat. David Perry), Kelowna Now, June 29, 2022

What slowdown? Canada's economy to top G7 on high oil, crop prices

by Julie Gordon and Rod Gordon (feat. Kevin Birn), Saltwire, June 29, 2022

Alliance renforcée

by Céline Galipeau (feat. Stefanie von Hlatky), Le Tele Journal, June 29, 2022

1.6 million public chargers needed in Canada for EV transition

by Larysa Harapyn (feat. Brian Kingston), The Financial Post, June 29, 2022

Passport? What passport?

by Martin C. Barr (feat. Andrew Griffith), Laval News, June 29, 2022

Oil production test looms for OPEC heavyweights Saudi Arabia, UAE

by Editorial Staff (feat. Ellen Wald), S&P Global, June 29, 2022

Eric Nuttall & Amrita Sen - Oil & Energy Update

by Eric Nuttall (feat. Amrita Sen), Nine Point Partners, June 29, 2022

All talk, no traction

by Maura Forest and Andy Blatchford (feat. Robert Huebert), Politico, June 29, 2022

U.S. pushes for Russian oil price ceiling. Feasible?

by Matt Levin (feat. Ellen Wald), MARKETPLACE, June 28, 2022

Russia Ukraine Update

by Susan Bonner (feat. Andrew Rasiulis), CBC Radio One, June 28, 2022

Un sommet de l’OTAN pour tenir tête à la Russie

by Marie Vastel (feat. David Perry), Le Devoir, June 26, 2022

A geopolitical alternative system of co-operation for nations

by Staff Reporter (feat. Swaran Singh), The Zimbabwe Mail, June 26, 2022

Analyst says high oil prices spurs little drilling

by Lee Harding (feat. Kevin Birn), Western Standard, June 26, 2022

It’s time for Canada to get serious about defence

by John Ibbitson (feat. James Fergusson and Rob Huebert), The Globe and Mail, June 25, 2022

Trudeau meets with Rwandan president, expands diplomatic mission in Kigali

by CBC Newsroom Staff (feat. Colin Robertson), CBC Newroom, June 24, 2022

With New Threats Looming, Canada Commits Billions to Air Defense

by News Desk (feat. Andrea Charron), New Express News, June 24, 2022

Drop in oil prices is not a quick fix for global inflation

by Editorial Staff (feat. Amrita Sen), The National, June 24, 2022

Highs and Lows of the Spring Sitting

by Peter Van Dusen (feat. Andrew Griffith), Prime Time Politics, June 24, 2022

Oil Incurs Second Weekly Loss As Analysts Differ On Inflation, Demand

by Ship and Bunker News Team (feat. Amrita Sen), Ship And Bunker, June 24, 2022


LATEST TWEETS

HEAD OFFICE
Canadian Global Affairs Institute
Suite 1800, 150–9th Avenue SW
Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2P 3H9

 

OTTAWA OFFICE
Canadian Global Affairs Institute
8 York Street, 2nd Floor
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada K1N 5S6

 

Phone: (613) 288-2529
Email: [email protected]
Web: cgai.ca

 

Making sense of our complex world.
Déchiffrer la complexité de notre monde.

 

© 2002-2022 Canadian Global Affairs Institute
Charitable Registration No. 87982 7913 RR0001

 


Sign in with Facebook | Sign in with Twitter | Sign in with Email