In Position: How Canada can win in a NAFTA renegotiation

How_Canada_can_win_Montages.jpg

OP-ED

by Sarah Goldfeder

Communitech News
February 14, 2017

Despite the storm clouds on the horizon, a new stage in the development of the Trump administration has begun. More members of cabinet are in office and appointments in the second tier (not subject to Senate confirmation) are falling into place. The bureaucracy is slowly starting to adapt to a new administration and the White House is slowly starting to see the benefits of working with its public service. The fallout from some of the early executive actions has begun to settle, and the talking points are building in consistency. If and how this trajectory progresses is still unclear.

Canada came to Washington this past Monday prepared to talk about specific areas of interest. One of the priorities was trade, including what the renegotiation of NAFTA may entail. The preparation clearly paid off in a visit that went off without a hitch. Chrystia Freeland, in particular, has been preparing, first as the Minister of International Trade and now as the Minister of Foreign Affairs, for what is coming. But the reality is that governments don’t trade. People and businesses do. Is Canada ready for a renegotiation of NAFTA? Even if Ms. Freeland and the government of Canada are, the answer for business is an overwhelming no.

The private sector, both businesses and individuals, should be taking inventory of its requirements for a free-trade agreement with the United States, with Mexico, and trilaterally. NAFTA has fulfilled some of these requirements, the Transpacific Partnership was slated to fill others and some are as yet missing from the free-trade agenda. When assessing trade with continental partners, the private sector should be prepared to list and quantify not just what it brings to the table, but what it wants to open for discussion.

The United States is at a disadvantage heading into trade negotiations. Mexico and Canada are working with established negotiating teams, with proven leadership and experience on successfully obtaining bilateral and multilateral agreements. The White House has already indicated that it intends to move the trade team from the United States Trade Representative (USTR) office to the Department of Commerce. Compounding the new alignment within the executive branch, the leadership of the trade team has yet to be installed. President Trump may be tweeting that he wants the NAFTA renegotiation to begin yesterday, but the reality is that the United States is simply not ready.

The proposed Secretary of Commerce, Wilbur Ross, has yet to be confirmed, and Robert Lighthizer, the nominee for USTR, is still awaiting a waiver before he can begin his hearings in committee. Peter Navarro, the head of the newly minted (and White House housed) National Trade Council, is not subject to Senate confirmation and presumably is on the job. All three members of the trade trifecta have substantial experience in trade actions and litigation but very little in negotiating. Not a one has expertise in the North American relationship and the implications for NAFTA on immigration, human rights, and continental security.

This could be an opportunity for Canada. Mexico has already realized the potential for its national interests and has begun a white paper incorporating its negotiating position. Canada, rather than be consumed with what the United States will want to renegotiate, should focus on building the trilateral framework that will benefit its national interest. Canada needs an offensive playbook right now, in addition to a defensive one. Lobbying its partners in business throughout the states and reminding local U.S. politicians of how many of their jobs rely on NAFTA, and specifically on Canada, does not constitute an offense. Canada should prepare a technical, granular analysis of how the trade relationship works and where it could work better and share that with its allies on the southern side of the border, beginning that work in the private sector here in Canada.

The government is in the process of examining the Canadian economy and looking to sectors are affected by the rules laid out in NAFTA. Businesses and their leadership are on the front lines of trade and have the information on how changes could be particularly beneficial to the Canadian economy and how they could be detrimental. They additionally have the ability to quantify exactly why. Minister Freeland has already demonstrated that she understands the role that businesses can play as advocates. Now, as she moves into preparing for this trade negotiations, the detail work begins — sector by sector, regional impacts and employment/GDP importance. The government will want to be clear about the most desirable possible outcomes and the red lines that are deal breakers. Improvements that Canada might want to seek to NAFTA exist not just in broad terms, but in very specific ways — including entire sectors of the economy that did not exist at the genesis of NAFTA that now need to be included in the conversation.

We should not be lulled into false confidence by the suggestion that there may only be “tweaks” in the trade relationship between the United States and Canada. The private sector must become involved in these impending negotiations and it is the business community which should be driving this conversation with government, not the other way around. Businesses should remind government who, in the end, is responsible for providing jobs and maintaining growth in a market-based economy like Canada’s. There is no reason that Canada, coming into negotiations demonstrating the command of the vocabulary, process and details of the negotiating process that its trade team has honed on agreements like TPP and CETA, should not have the upper hand.

Sarah Goldfeder is a principal at Earnscliffe Strategy Group and a fellow at the Canadian Global Affairs Institute. A former U.S. diplomat, she served as special assistant to two U.S. ambassadors to Canada.

Image: Martin Deutsch

 


Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTERS
 
SEARCH
PODCAST

Canada's State of Trade: Getting Our Goods To Market

May 17, 2018


On today's Global Exchange Podcast, we continue our series on the state of Canadian trade in a world of growing populism and protectionism. Today's episode, recorded during our February 13th State of Trade conference in Ottawa, features Bruce Borrows, Jennifer Fox, and David Miller in conversation with the Wilson Center's Laura Dawson about getting Canadian goods to international markets.


IN THE MEDIA

Between Trump, Iran and North Korea, Canada’s G7 has a high potential for chaos

by Chris Hall (feat. James Trottier & Colin Robertson), CBC News, May 18, 2018

The struggle Trudeau could face if Kinder Morgan walks away from Trans Mountain

by Robert Tuttle & Michael Bellusci (feat. Dennis McConaghy), Bloomberg News, May 18, 2018

Canada 'a laughing stock': Experts react to Trans Mountain indemnity

by April Fong (feat. Dennis McConaghy), BNN Bloomberg, May 18, 2018

AUDIO: NAFTA update

with Danielle Smith (feat. Sarah Goldfeder), Global News Radio, May 18, 2018

VIDEO: NAFTA Deadline Day (@ 3:00)

with Don Martin (feat. John Weekes), CTV Power Play, May 17, 2018

VIDEO: Deal or no deal on NAFTA: Canada and U.S. send mixed messages

with Rosemary Barton (feat. Colin Robertson), CBC The National, May 17, 2018

Trump’s 'submission' strategy is not working so expect NAFTA talks to drag on

by Kevin Carmichael (Feat. Eric Miller), Financial Post, May 17, 2018

Backstop deal may be last hope for TransMountain pipeline, says former oil executive

by CBC News (feat. Dennis McConaghy), CBC News, May 17, 2018

Stuck with limited oil export options, Liberals may regret B.C. tanker ban

by John Ivison (feat. Dennis McConaghy), National Post, May 17, 2018

Feds OK early start to construction of navy’s new supply ships

by Lee Berthiaume (feat. Dave Perry), The Canadian Press, May 17, 2018


LATEST TWEETS

HEAD OFFICE
Canadian Global Affairs Institute
Suite 1800, 421-7th Avenue SW
Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2P 4K9

 

OTTAWA OFFICE
Canadian Global Affairs Institute
8 York Street, 2nd Floor
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada K1N 5S6

 

Phone: (613) 288-2529
Email: contact@cgai.ca
Web: cgai.ca

 

Making sense of our complex world.
Déchiffrer la complexité de notre monde.

 

© 2002-2018 Canadian Global Affairs Institute
Charitable Registration No. 87982 7913 RR0001

 


Sign in with Facebook | Sign in with Twitter | Sign in with Email