'Global Outlook' by David Bercuson

Nuclear "tactics" an oxymoron

by David Bercuson

Frontline Magazine
May 16, 2017

Last March negotiations began at the United Nations in New York to produce a “legally binding instrument to prohibit nuclear weapons, leading toward their total elimination.” The United States and most of its close allies are not taking part in the talks, leading at least two proponents of the talks to conclude that “their refusal to participate is flawed on substance and probably in breach of their NPT obligation to promote nuclear disarmament.  It is also a self-defeating tactic as they are rejecting the opportunity to influence the debate and shape the text of the eventual treaty.” (Globe and Mail, March 27, 2017). Perhaps the real difference between the U.S. and its close allies (including Canada) and the other nations taking part in the discussions is that the former know that nuclear weapons are inevitably and completely here to stay, while the rest of the nations represented at the talks simply like to send self-important delegations to fancy hotels and even fancier restaurants in the pretence that they are doing something useful to make the world safer.

The world’s nine nuclear weapons states – the UN Security Council’s Big Five – have been nuclear-armed for decades.  None of them would give up their nuclear weapons because to do so would diminish their status as veto-wielding countries and undermine the only real defence against nuclear weapons, which is deterrence. The newer members of the nuclear club – India and Pakistan, North Korea and probably Israel – have their own reasons for having gone nuclear. For Pakistan, it’s because India developed them, and for Israel it’s the ultimate deterrent – especially now against Iran. North Korea sees nuclear weapons as a means of raising its status from a poor undeveloped nation to one whose every twitch makes the world’s genuine great powers twitch at every turn.

Ironically, nuclear weapons themselves do not pose significant real-life danger because of the deterrent factor: you hit me and I’ll hit you back.  This kept nuclear peace during the last Cold War.  More dangerous is the miniaturization of nuclear weapons and their combination with precision-guided munitions in an attempt to make them “safer” to actually use in a conflict.  When a small nuke can take out an army base without endangering the safety of whole populations, the temptation to use such weapons will soar.  And so will the possibility that crossing the nuclear threshold will inevitably lead up Herman Kahn’s ladder of escalation to city-busting and the annihilation of tens if not hundreds of millions of people.

It’s way too late to eliminate nuclear weapons. The best course at this point is to try to get existing nuclear powers to refrain from the development of super-small nukes they would be tempted to use for tactical purposes.  In nuclear war, the word “tactical” would lose all meaning.

David Bercuson is Research Director of the Canadian Global Affairs Institute.


Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
Donate to Canadian Global Affairs Institute Subscribe
 

SEARCH


 

EVENTS

4th Annual Defence Procurement Conference
October 26th, 2017
Ottawa, Ontario

David Frum - Speaker Series Dinner
November 15th, 2017
Calgary, Alberta

 

IN THE MEDIA


Trump has changed the game for Canadian politicians
by Kaitlin Lee (feat. Colin Robertson), 660 News, July 21, 2017

Trump's Modest Proposal for a Nafta Revamp
by Patrick Coyle, Andrew Mayeda, Josh Wingrove, and Eric Martin (feat. Eric Miller), Bloomberg, July 20, 2017

 

LATEST TWEETS


Donate | Submit | Media Inquiries
Making sense of our complex world. | Déchiffrer la complexité de notre monde.
 
HEAD OFFICE
Canadian Global Affairs Institute

Suite 1600, 530 8th Avenue SW
Calgary, Alberta, Canada  T2P 3S8
 
OTTAWA OFFICE
Canadian Global Affairs Institute

8 York Street, 2nd Floor
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada  K1N 5S6

Phone: (613) 288-2529 
Email: contact@cgai.ca 
Web: cgai.ca
 
2002-2015 Canadian Global Affairs Institute

Charitable Registration No.  87982 7913 RR0001